Lili (1953) – full review!
This delightful little musical romance drama was directed by Charles Waters and features a screenplay by Helen Deutsch from a story by Paul Gallico (The Pride of the Yankees (1942)). It stars Leslie Caron in the title role; she sings the catchy song “Hi-Lilli. Hi-Lo” which was written by Deutsch and Bronislau Kaper who won his only Academy Award for writing its Score. Caron earned the first of her two unrewarded Best Actress Oscar nominations. Waters and Deutsch received their only Academy recognition with Best Director and Screenplay Oscar nominations respectively. Color Cinematographer Robert Planck earned the last of his four unrewarded nominations. The cast also includes Mel Ferrer Jean Pierre Aumont Zsa Zsa Gabor & Kurt Kasznar (among others) and four puppets (given life and voices ostensibly from Ferrer and Kasznar).
Lili Daurier (Caron) is a sweet innocent recently orphaned (when her father died) French girl of sixteen who’s traveled to a coastal town in hopes of finding work and a home with a baker friend of her deceased father. Unfortunately he too had died recently; she learns from the proprietor of an adjacent store (Alex Gerry) who’s about to take advantage of her until another man prevents it. That man turns out to be Marcus the Magnificent (Aumont) a magician with the circus troupe that’s in town. Like a little duck Lili follows Marc meeting two of his fellow performers puppeteers actually Paul Berthalet (Ferrer) and Jacquot (Kasznar). Marc quickly learns how naive and ignorant in the ways of the world (& of being a woman) Lili is but he doesn’t take advantage of her. Instead he convinces a cabaret manager (Ralph Dumke) to hire her. But Lili loses the job after one night because she can’t handle being a waitress very well especially when she watches love-struck as Marc performs his show with his assistant Rosalie (Gabor). Upon being fired Lili goes to Marc hoping he’ll help her again but fed up with her cramping his style he tells her to grow up and go back to the original store owner who’d tried to take advantage of her. Downtrodden with nowhere to go she puts down her things and begins to climb a high-wire ladder to commit suicide when one of the puppets talks to her.
Of course the puppets are being controlled by Paul who had seen what Lili was about to do and decided to save her. Paul had been a great famous dancer but is now lame; he now finds that the most comfortable way for him to perform for an audience is by hiding behind a curtain. It has become virtually the only way in which he deals with others at all at least pleasantly. Paul’s puppets interact with Lili singing the aforementioned song with her and she laughs & forgets her troubles. The show is witnessed by other performers in the troupe who were entranced by it. Paul and his assistant Jacquot who only moves some of the puppets while Paul provides all the voices decide to ask Lili to join their act. Each evening Lili dresses in her same simple dress and interacts with the puppets as if they were real people. It’s her innocence which enables her to accept the four characters are being real which comes across to the audience and causes the act to become such a success that it’s recognized by some Paris agents (Wilton Graff & George Baxter).
Paul who’s the improvisational genius of the nightly performances has fallen in love with Lili. But alas Lili’s heart still belongs to Marc. She even dreams of him (there is a dance sequence featuring Lili “stealing” Marc away from Rosalie). She buys a new dress making herself look all grown up and approaches the magician’s trailer. Having just learned that his act is being hired by a Paris hotel he’s not as altruistic nor noble towards Lili. In fact Marc goes with her to her trailer which she shares with Paul & Jacquot but before anything can happen they’re interrupted by Paul’s return. Naturally Paul is heartbroken once more; he even slaps Lili when she runs after Marc to return something he’d dropped. Later Lili realizes that what Marc had left in the trailer was his wedding ring and that he’s really married to Rosalie – a fact the duo had purposely kept secret for business purposes (e.g. Marc attracts a large female paying audience). Lili returns the ring to Marc and begins to leave altogether but again the puppets bring her back (and not just because Paul needs her for the act before it too can go to Paris). Suddenly she draws back the curtain to reveal Paul who in the film’s most powerful scene tells her why the puppets’ characterizations are so real and heartfelt – each is a reflection of a different part of his own personality which he’s too afraid to reveal on a person-to-person (human) level:
I am Carrot Top: confident clever capable of running his life and yours and everybody else’s; and I’m Golo the Giant: cowardly stupid longing to be loved clumsy and in need of comforting; and I’m Marguerite too: vain jealous obsessed with self looking at my face in the mirror – are my teeth nice? Is my hair growing thin? And I’m Reynaldo: the thief the opportunist full of compromise and lies like any other man. I have in me all these things.
But remembering his slap Lili leaves anyway only to return (after another imagined sequence in which the puppets are people-size each dancing with her before one-by-one they become Paul and walk back towards where she’s been) to Paul in the end.